UPSC Current Editorials - Upsc Exam Notes

General Studies 2 >> Polity

EDITORIAL ANALYSIS: The post of Deputy Speaker is not symbolic or optional

The post of Deputy Speaker is not symbolic or optional

Source: The Hindu

For Prelims

What:
The editorial examines the constitutional and functional significance of the Office of the Deputy Speaker of the Lok Sabha, highlighting its neglect in recent years despite being a mandatory post under Article 93 of the Constitution.

Why:
The role of the Deputy Speaker is essential for ensuring continuity and neutrality in parliamentary proceedings. The prolonged vacancy of this office undermines constitutional norms and raises concerns about institutional integrity and democratic balance.

Who:
The article mentions Sachidanand Sinha (first Deputy President under British rule), M.A. Ayyangar (first elected Deputy Speaker of the Lok Sabha), and G.V. Mavalankar (first Speaker of the Lok Sabha) to contextualize the evolution of this office. It also references constitutional experts like S.C. Kashyap.

Outcome:
The editorial calls for immediate restoration of the Deputy Speaker's post, possibly even through legislative reform mandating a time-bound election to prevent such prolonged constitutional anomalies in the future

For Mains

GS II: Polity, Governance, and Constitution

1. Analyze the constitutional importance of the Office of the Deputy Speaker and the implications of its prolonged vacancy.

Article 93 mandates the election of a Speaker and Deputy Speaker “as soon as may be,” denoting urgency and necessity.
The Deputy Speaker acts as a constitutional safeguard to ensure continuity in the event of the Speaker’s absence, resignation, or death.

2. Evaluate the implications of not adhering to constitutional conventions such as appointing a Deputy Speaker from the Opposition.

Conventionally, the post is offered to the Opposition, fostering bipartisan respect and democratic inclusiveness.
The denial of this convention signals increasing centralization of power and erosion of consensus politics.

3. Should there be legislative reform to enforce timely appointment of the Deputy Speaker?

The absence of a timeline creates a constitutional loophole, enabling inaction.
Proposals include setting a 60-day deadline post-Lok Sabha formation or empowering the President to intervene on advice

Highlights of the Editorial

UPSC EXAM NOTES ANALYSIS

Article 93

Legislative or procedural reforms

Colonial-era Central Legislative Assembly

1. Constitutional Mandate

Article 93 mandates election of both Speaker and Deputy Speaker.
The phrase “as soon as may be” implies urgency, not convenience.
Article 94 ensures continuity by keeping the Deputy Speaker in office unless removed or resigns.

2. Historical Context

Originates from the colonial-era Central Legislative Assembly.
Role institutionalized post-Independence, with notable figures like M.A. Ayyangar demonstrating its functional importance during crises.

3. Functional Necessity

Deputy Speaker ensures parliamentary continuity in Speaker’s absence.
Presides over committees and debates, and is expected to act with impartiality.
Balances procedural power, especially during contentious or sensitive sessions.

4. Symbol of Bipartisanship

Long-standing convention of offering the post to the Opposition.
Strengthens trust and accountability in parliamentary functioning.
Its abandonment weakens the non-partisan ethos of the legislature.

5. Constitutional Vacuum

The 17th Lok Sabha (2019–2024) had no Deputy Speaker throughout its tenure.
18th Lok Sabha, as of now, continues this neglect.
This is unprecedented and constitutionally anomalous.

6. Risks of Vacancy

Absence risks a leadership vacuum during emergencies.
Consolidates power within the ruling party and Speaker, eroding checks and balances.
Undermines institutional norms and democratic ethics.

7. Need for Reform

Suggests amending procedures to enforce time-bound election.
Proposes empowering the President to act within a stipulated time on Prime Ministerial advice.
Advocates restoring the convention of Opposition representation for greater legitimacy

Conclusion

The editorial strongly argues that the Office of the Deputy Speaker is a constitutional necessity, not an optional or symbolic appointment. Its prolonged vacancy reflects a dangerous disregard for constitutional morality and democratic accountability. Timely election, possibly through legislative or procedural reforms, is essential to preserve the balance, continuity, and integrity of India’s parliamentary democracy

Mains Practice Questions

The Office of the Deputy Speaker is a constitutional necessity, not a ceremonial post. In the context of the prolonged vacancy of the Deputy Speaker’s post in the Lok Sabha, critically examine the constitutional provisions, conventions, and implications for parliamentary democracy in India.
“As soon as may be” under Article 93 has been interpreted loosely, leading to a constitutional vacuum. Do you think a time-bound mandate should be introduced for the election of the Deputy Speaker? Justify your answer with reference to constitutional safeguards and democratic values.
Discuss the importance of the Deputy Speaker’s post in ensuring the continuity and impartiality of Lok Sabha proceedings. How does the prolonged vacancy affect the checks and balances within parliamentary functioning?
Parliamentary conventions, though unwritten, are vital for the democratic ethos of the legislature. Examine the significance of the convention of offering the Deputy Speaker’s post to the Opposition and the consequences of its disregard.
The vacant post of the Deputy Speaker of Lok Sabha has exposed a gap between constitutional intent and political practice. Should India consider legislative reforms to enforce timely appointment to such positions? Analyze with suitable suggestions.

Share to Social

UPSC Editorial