INTEGRATED MAINS AND PRELIMS MENTORSHIP (IMPM) 2025 Daily KEY
| Exclusive for Subscribers Daily:
Obesity and Air Quality Index (AQI), Particulate matter (PM) and its significance for the UPSC Exam? Why are topics like Dark Patterns , Jal Jeevan Missionimportant for both preliminary and main exams? Discover more insights in the UPSC Exam Notes for May 31, 2025 |
🚨 UPSC EXAM NOTES presents the March edition of our comprehensive monthly guide. Access it to enhance your preparation. We value your input - share your thoughts and recommendations in the comments section or via email at Support@upscexamnotes.com 🚨
Critical Topics and Their Significance for the UPSC CSE Examination on May 31, 2025
Daily Insights and Initiatives for UPSC Exam Notes: Comprehensive explanations and high-quality material provided regularly for students
For Preliminary Examination: Current events of national and international significance
For Mains Examination: GS III - General Science
Context:
Red-flagging the rising rates of obesity and hypertension among school-going children, a new study by the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) has found that the prevalence of obesity was as high as 24.02 per cent in private schools, more than five times the number for public schools
Read about:
What’s the obesity map?
What’s the nature of obesity?
Key takeaways:
-
This is particularly troubling, as both factors can increase the likelihood of developing diabetes and cardiovascular conditions later in life.
-
A study involving 3,888 students aged between 6 and 19 from schools in Delhi revealed that, on average, 13.4% were generally obese, and 9.2% exhibited abdominal (central) obesity. These figures mark a significant increase compared to a similar 2006 study, which had reported only 5% prevalence of obesity.
-
The rate of obesity was notably higher in private schools, with 24.02% of students showing general obesity and 16.77% central obesity. In contrast, government schools recorded much lower rates—4.48% and 1.83%, respectively.
-
Despite these differences, both types of schools showed a comparable prevalence of hypertension, around 7.4%. However, students from private institutions were found to be twice as likely to have elevated blood sugar levels and three times more likely to exhibit metabolic syndrome—a combination of conditions that heighten the risk of diabetes and heart disease.
-
A particularly worrying finding is the high occurrence of dyslipidemia, affecting roughly 34% of children. This condition reflects abnormal levels of lipids in the blood, including irregular cholesterol, triglycerides, HDL (good cholesterol), and LDL (bad cholesterol).
-
Additionally, private school students were 2.37 times more likely to have impaired fasting glucose levels and 3.51 times more prone to metabolic syndrome compared to their public school peers
- Obesity among school-aged children has emerged as a serious public health concern, particularly because it is closely linked to an increased risk of developing diabetes and cardiovascular diseases later in adulthood.
- A recent study conducted among 3,888 students aged between 6 and 19 years from various schools in Delhi highlighted the growing scale of this issue. The findings revealed that, on average, 13.4% of these students were classified as generally obese, while 9.2% exhibited central or abdominal obesity—conditions associated with a higher likelihood of chronic metabolic disorders.
- These numbers indicate a sharp rise when compared to a similar study conducted in 2006, which reported only a 5% obesity rate.
- The study further showed significant disparities between private and public schools. Students in private schools exhibited much higher rates of obesity, with 24.02% affected by general obesity and 16.77% by central obesity.
- In contrast, the prevalence in public schools was considerably lower, with general obesity at 4.48% and central obesity at just 1.83%. While the incidence of hypertension was found to be roughly the same across both types of schools, at about 7.4%, other health indicators presented a more concerning picture for private school students.
- They were found to be twice as likely to have elevated blood sugar levels and three times more likely to suffer from metabolic syndrome—a cluster of conditions that typically precedes diabetes and heart disease.
- Another alarming aspect revealed by the study was the presence of dyslipidemia in nearly 34% of the children surveyed. This condition, characterized by abnormal levels of lipids in the blood, includes irregularities in cholesterol, triglycerides, and both good (HDL) and bad (LDL) cholesterol levels.
- Notably, the likelihood of private school students having impaired fasting plasma glucose was 2.37 times higher, and their chances of developing metabolic syndrome were 3.51 times greater than their counterparts in public schools
1.Consider the following statements regarding childhood obesity in India:
-
Central obesity refers to excess fat accumulation around the abdomen and is a key risk factor for metabolic syndrome.
-
According to a recent study in Delhi, the prevalence of general obesity was found to be higher in public schools than in private schools.
-
Dyslipidemia, a condition linked to obesity, involves abnormal levels of blood lipids such as cholesterol and triglycerides.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
a) 1 and 2 only
b) 1 and 3 only
c) 2 and 3 only
d) 1, 2 and 3
|
Answer (b)
|
Going beyond AQI: study shows why toxicity matters in measuring air pollution
For Preliminary Examination: Air Quality Index (AQI), CAQM
For Mains Examination: GS III - Environment and ecology
Context:
The ability of PM2.5 air pollutants to cause damage to cells increases sharply after concentration levels cross a certain threshold value, new research has found
Read about:
Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS)
Particulate matter (PM)
Key takeaways:
- A recent study has revealed that the potential of PM2.5 air pollutants to harm human cells rises significantly once their concentration surpasses a specific threshold. In the case of Kolkata, where the research was conducted, this critical threshold is around 70 micrograms per cubic metre (µg/m³).
- Beyond this point, the toxicity—or the capacity of these particles to damage the human body—escalates quickly until it reaches about 130 µg/m³, after which the rate of damage tends to level off, even if concentrations increase further.
- This pattern can be explained by the body's initial ability to manage lower levels of pollutant exposure. Below the threshold, the body’s natural defense systems can mitigate harmful effects to some extent.
- However, once pollutant concentrations cross the critical level, these defense mechanisms become overwhelmed, leading to greater cellular damage—especially in the respiratory system, which is the first to be affected.
- When these fine particles are inhaled, the immune system responds by generating Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS), chemical agents that help neutralize foreign invaders. But in doing so, ROS can also harm the body’s own cells. To counteract this, the body produces antioxidants that neutralize ROS and prevent cell damage.
- Unfortunately, antioxidant levels are naturally limited and are slow to replenish. While they can effectively manage small amounts of ROS, they are insufficient to deal with the large volumes produced under high pollutant exposure.
- This research has important implications for policy-making. Current air quality regulations focus primarily on the concentration of pollutants rather than their toxic potential.
- For instance, in India, the annual average safe limit for PM2.5 is set at 40 µg/m³, and the daily average limit is 60 µg/m³. However, the actual risk to human health also depends on the toxicity of the pollutants, which can vary with factors such as their chemical makeup.
- In Kolkata, for instance, the health risk from PM2.5 levels of 50 or 60 µg/m³ might not be significantly worse than those of 30–40 µg/m³. But once concentrations exceed 70 µg/m³, the threat increases sharply, necessitating urgent attention.
- It is important to note that this toxicity threshold may vary from one city to another, depending on local environmental and pollution characteristics
Follow Up Question
- Carbon dioxide
- Carbon monoxide
- Nitrogen dioxide
- Sulfur dioxide
- Methane
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
A. 1, 2 and 3 only
B. 2, 3 and 4 only
C. 1, 4 and 5 only
D. 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5
|
Answer (B)
The Air Quality Index (AQI) in India is calculated based on the concentrations of the following eight pollutants:
Now, evaluate the gases in the question:
|
What are ‘dark patterns’ in e-commerce?
For Preliminary Examination: Current events of national and international significance
For Mains Examination: GS III - Economy
Context:
To identify and eliminate dark patterns on e-commerce platforms, the government has asked e-commerce platforms to regularly conduct an audit on their platforms. “Companies must not wait for the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) to intervene.
Read about:
Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA)
What are dark patterns?
Key takeaways:
Dark patterns, also referred to as deceptive patterns, are design strategies employed by websites and mobile applications to manipulate users into taking actions they did not originally intend or to discourage actions that may not benefit the service provider. These tactics are typically designed to serve the business's interests over the user's.
A classic example can illustrate this concept: imagine an intrusive advertisement that repeatedly appears on your screen, where the 'X' button to close it is either too tiny to spot or deliberately hard to click. In many cases, when users attempt to tap or click the 'X', they mistakenly end up interacting with the ad itself. Such user interface tricks are a hallmark of dark patterns.
The term "dark patterns" was introduced in 2010 by Harry Brignull, a user experience designer based in London. Since then, countless instances of these manipulative tactics have surfaced across the internet. Recognizing their widespread use, the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) in India issued comprehensive guidelines on December 1, 2023, to regulate and prevent such practices, categorizing them into 13 specific types:
-
False urgency: This involves pressuring users to act quickly by fabricating scarcity or exaggerated popularity, prompting rushed decisions—often by showing limited stock or time-sensitive deals that aren't actually true.
-
Basket sneaking: This tactic adds extra items to a user’s cart without their knowledge or approval, thereby inflating the final purchase amount.
-
Confirm shaming: Users are made to feel guilty or socially pressured when they decline offers, often through emotionally manipulative language.
-
Forced action: This compels users to perform certain actions—like subscribing to a service—just to gain access to unrelated content or services.
-
Nagging: Users face continuous interruptions in the form of repeated messages or pop-ups urging them to take a specific action, unless they’ve explicitly agreed to such interruptions.
-
Subscription traps: These make it easy to sign up for services but deliberately make the cancellation process difficult or confusing, often hiding it behind several steps or unclear instructions. They may also require unnecessary payment information for a supposedly free trial.
-
Bait and switch: Here, a product or service is promoted under false pretenses, but the user receives something different, usually of inferior quality.
-
Rogue malware: This involves scare tactics such as pop-ups falsely claiming the presence of a virus, prompting users to download software that actually installs malicious programs.
-
Disguised advertisements: Ads are presented in a way that makes them resemble legitimate content, like news stories or user reviews, misleading users into interacting with them.
-
Interface interference: This includes the deliberate design of user interfaces to prioritize or conceal certain information, influencing users' choices by directing attention away from critical details.
-
Drip pricing: The full cost of a product or service is not disclosed upfront. Instead, additional charges are revealed gradually or only after a purchase decision has been made.
-
Trick questions: These use confusing language, such as double negatives or ambiguous phrasing, to mislead users into giving unintended responses or agreeing to something inadvertently.
-
SaaS billing manipulation: In the software-as-a-service (SaaS) model, this involves exploiting recurring billing cycles and user acquisition patterns to charge users subtly and repeatedly, often without clear consent.
Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA)
-
The Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) was established under Section 10(1) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which replaced the earlier Consumer Protection Act of 1986. This updated legislation, effective from July 24, 2020, broadens the legal framework for consumer rights in India. It is designed to safeguard consumer interests by addressing unfair trade practices and curbing misleading or false advertisements that may harm consumers or the general public.
-
The CCPA is empowered to initiate investigations or inquiries into violations of consumer rights and unfair trade practices on its own (suo motu), in response to complaints, or upon directions from the central government.
-
According to the Act, the CCPA is composed of a Chief Commissioner and a designated number of Commissioners, as determined by government regulations. These officials are appointed by the Central Government and are responsible for executing the authority’s functions as outlined in the Act.
-
The Central Government is also authorized to frame rules related to the eligibility, appointment process, tenure, salaries, allowances, resignation procedures, removal, and other service conditions for the Chief Commissioner and the Commissioners of the CCPA.
-
Additionally, the CCPA includes an Investigation Wing led by a Director General, and District Collectors are also empowered to look into cases involving violations of consumer rights, deceptive advertisements, and unfair trade practices at the local level.
|
Answer (D)
The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 brought several new provisions to strengthen consumer rights in India. Let’s evaluate each option:
|
A bow echo is a distinctive radar signature that appears as a curved or bow-shaped line of thunderstorms on weather radar displays. The name comes from its characteristic crescent or arc shape that resembles an archer's bow when viewed from above.
Key Characteristics
Radar Appearance The bow echo shows up on Doppler radar as a curved line of intense precipitation, typically 50-400 kilometers (30-250 miles) long. The center of the bow often shows weaker reflectivity due to strong downdrafts, while the edges maintain intense precipitation cores.
Structure Components
- Bookend vortices: Rotating circulations at each end of the bow
- Rear inflow jet: Strong winds flowing into the back of the storm system
- Weak echo region: An area of reduced precipitation in the center caused by downdrafts
- Forward flank downdraft: Descending air that creates surface wind damage
Formation Process
Bow echoes typically form when:
- A line of thunderstorms (squall line) develops asymmetric downdrafts
- Strong rear-to-front winds accelerate the center of the line forward
- The line bows outward, creating the characteristic curved shape
- Bookend vortices develop at the tips, helping maintain the structure
Meteorological Significance
Wind Production Bow echoes are primarily known for producing damaging straight-line winds at the surface, often reaching 60-100+ mph. These winds result from strong downdrafts that hit the ground and spread outward horizontally.
Storm Evolution They represent an intermediate stage between ordinary squall lines and more complex mesoscale convective systems. Some bow echoes can evolve into derechos when they persist and produce widespread wind damage over hundreds of miles.
Forecasting Importance The bow echo signature on radar is a critical warning sign for meteorologists, indicating that damaging winds are likely occurring or imminent, prompting the issuance of severe thunderstorm warnings.
1.Consider the following statements regarding Bow Echo:
- It appears as a curved or bow-shaped line of thunderstorms on weather radar displays.
- Bow echoes are primarily associated with rotating supercell thunderstorms that produce tornadoes.
- The characteristic feature of bow echoes is the production of damaging straight-line winds at the surface.
- When bow echoes progress more than 250 miles with widespread wind gusts, they can develop into derechos.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only
(b) 1, 3 and 4 only
(c) 2, 3 and 4 only
(d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
|
Answer (b)
Statement 1: CORRECT ✓
Statement 2: INCORRECT ✗
Statement 3: CORRECT ✓
Statement 4: CORRECT ✓
|
For Preliminary Examination: Current events of national and international Significance
For Mains Examination: General Studies II: Important aspects of governance
Context:
A number of MPs on Thursday sought an investigation into the alleged irregularities in the implementation of the government’s flagship Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM)
Read about:
What is the issue highlighted in Jal Jeevan Mission ?
Is the Jal Jeevan Mission a centrally sponsored scheme?
Key takeaways:
- The Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM) was launched by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on August 15, 2019, with the goal of providing piped water connections to 16 crore rural households by the end of December 2024, aiming for universal access.
- However, in the first five years, only 75% of the target was achieved. As a result, the government has decided to extend the mission’s deadline by another four years, setting a new completion date of December 31, 2028, to reach the remaining 4 crore households.
- At the time of the launch of the 'Har Ghar Jal' initiative in 2019, the Expenditure Finance Committee (EFC) sanctioned an outlay of Rs 3.6 lakh crore, although the Jal Shakti Ministry had sought Rs 7.89 lakh crore. Despite this, data on the mission's dashboard indicates that states approved schemes amounting to Rs 8.07 lakh crore between 2019 and 2024.
- This substantial rise in projected costs likely influenced the EFC’s decision to scale down the budget and limit the Centre’s contribution. Sources suggest that during an EFC meeting, the ministry defended the Rs 8.07 lakh crore requirement, which covered Rs 7.68 lakh crore in awarded works and Rs 38,940 crore for projects nearing award.
- Since the mission’s inception, the government has successfully provided piped water connections to approximately 12 crore rural homes.
- The combined spending by the Centre and states amounted to Rs 3.60 lakh crore (with the Centre contributing Rs 2.08 lakh crore and states Rs 1.52 lakh crore).
- To connect the remaining households, the Department of Drinking Water and Sanitation (DDWS) has estimated an additional Rs 5.5 lakh crore will be required — Rs 2.79 lakh crore from the Centre and Rs 2.71 lakh crore from the states.
- These financial requirements were highlighted during an informal gathering chaired by Jal Shakti Minister C. R. Patil, which addressed the concerns raised by Members of Parliament (MPs) during the discussion on the ministry’s budget demands for FY 2025–26.
- The meeting occurred shortly after the government deployed 100 inspection teams across 135 districts in 29 states and Union Territories to assess the scheme’s progress amid rising concerns about budget overruns and suspected irregularities in the awarding of contracts.
- Despite invitations extended to 60 Lok Sabha MPs, only about 17 to 18 attended the session held at Parliament House Annexe, according to sources. The ministry refrained from issuing an official statement, though Minister Patil later posted on X (formerly Twitter) that the MPs provided "constructive" feedback.
- Earlier, a panel led by the Expenditure Secretary had proposed a 46% reduction in the ministry’s request for Rs 2.79 lakh crore in central funding to support the mission through December 2028. This was largely due to apprehensions that some states had approved inflated project contracts under the scheme.
- Since 2019, states have sanctioned 6.4 lakh water supply schemes with a combined estimated cost of Rs 8.29 lakh crore, more than double the original financial plan of Rs 3.60 lakh crore.
- To bridge the funding gap, the ministry had requested the EFC to approve an additional Rs 2.79 lakh crore, but only Rs 1.51 lakh crore was cleared — marking a 46% shortfall from the ministry’s proposed allocation.
- A report published by The Indian Express on May 21 revealed that a key amendment in tender regulations three years prior had removed financial checks, contributing to significant cost increases. As a result, 14,586 schemes saw a 14.58% hike, adding Rs 16,839 crore in unforeseen expenses.
- During the recent Thursday meeting, ministry officials gave presentations on various programmes, including Jal Jeevan Mission and Namami Gange. It is understood that written responses will be sent to MPs who raised questions, and a follow-up session is expected during the upcoming Monsoon session of Parliament
Follow Up Question
1. What is water stress? How and why does it differ regionally in India? (2019)
The importance of the Deputy Speaker
For Preliminary Examination: Current events of national and international significance
For Mains Examination: GS II - Indian Polity & Governance
Context:
The position of the Deputy Speaker has been lying vacant for the last six years raising questions on constitutional adherence and democratic resilience. The position goes beyond ceremonial significance and is indispensable to parliamentary democracy
Read about:
Deputy Speaker
Parliamentary Committees
Key takeaways:
Vacancy of Deputy Speaker: A Constitutional and Democratic Concern
- The post of Deputy Speaker in the Lok Sabha has remained unfilled for over six years, raising serious concerns about constitutional compliance and the health of India’s parliamentary democracy.
- Far from being symbolic, this role is fundamental to the functioning of the legislature. The persistent vacancy necessitates a closer examination of key constitutional principles. India’s founding fathers chose the parliamentary form of governance to ensure meaningful representation of its citizens.
- This vision is undermined if institutional mechanisms do not operate effectively and seamlessly. Meaningful dialogue between the ruling party and the Opposition is essential for accountability and the preservation of democratic checks and balances.
- Allegations have surfaced that the present ruling party has deliberately withheld the Deputy Speaker’s position from the Opposition, contravening the spirit of power-sharing—an essential feature of any thriving parliamentary democracy.
- It's worth noting that constitutional conventions, though unwritten, often carry the force of law when statutory provisions are silent.
The Importance of the Deputy Speaker’s Role
- The Deputy Speaker is far more than just a backup for the Speaker; he or she ensures legislative continuity and presides over significant parliamentary activities, including debates, the scrutiny of private member’s bills, and the Budget Committee.
- The office is established under Article 93 of the Constitution, which employs the phrase “as soon as” in reference to electing both the Speaker and Deputy Speaker—indicating urgency, not discretion.
- Article 94 also underlines that the Deputy Speaker holds office until resignation, removal, or disqualification, reinforcing the role’s continuity.
- Traditionally, while the Speaker is chosen from the ruling party, the Deputy Speaker’s post is informally offered to the Opposition as a goodwill gesture, fostering cooperation between both sides of the aisle and facilitating smoother parliamentary functioning.
Implications of a Prolonged Vacancy
- No Deputy Speaker was appointed during the 17th Lok Sabha (2019–2024), and there seems to be little indication that this will change in the 18th Lok Sabha. The government and the Opposition’s inability to reach a consensus—likely due to the ruling party’s unwillingness to concede the position to the Opposition—is troubling.
- According to Rule 8 of the Lok Sabha's Rules of Procedure (1952), the Speaker is responsible for setting a date for the Deputy Speaker’s election, which is held through a formal motion. When presiding over the House, the Deputy Speaker holds the same powers as the Speaker.
- Furthermore, under Article 180, the Deputy Speaker assumes the Speaker’s responsibilities when the chair is vacant. Hence, the continued vacancy violates not only Articles 93, 94, and 180 of the Constitution but also disregards procedural rules.
Constitutional and Democratic Consequences
- Though Article 93 mandates the election of a Deputy Speaker “as soon as may be,” its lack of a defined timeframe has enabled potential misuse, leading to extended delays and undermining constitutional intent.
- Traditionally, this position has been held by an Opposition member, helping to balance power. Its current vacancy centralizes authority in the Speaker, who is often from the ruling party, thereby disrupting the intended democratic balance.
- Constitutional conventions are meant to uphold a healthy equilibrium between the government and the Opposition, ensuring robust debate and effective legislative functioning, in line with the Westminster model. In the event of the Speaker’s resignation or incapacity, the absence of a Deputy Speaker could trigger a constitutional crisis with serious implications for governance
Follow Up Question
1.Which of the following statements regarding the Deputy Speaker of the Lok Sabha is/are correct?
-
The Deputy Speaker is elected by the members of the Lok Sabha from amongst themselves.
-
As per the Constitution, the Deputy Speaker must belong to the Opposition party.
-
In the absence of the Speaker, the Deputy Speaker performs all the duties of the Speaker.
-
The Constitution prescribes a fixed time frame for the election of the Deputy Speaker.
Select the correct answer using the code below:
(a) 1 and 3 only
(b) 1, 2 and 3 only
(c) 2 and 4 only
(d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
|
Answer (a)
|
Should water be used as a weapon?
For Preliminary Examination: Current events of antional and international Significance
For Mains Examination: GS II - International treaties
Context:
All is fair in love and war is a phrase that has literary roots and rhetorical appeal, suggesting that in matters of passion and conflict, rules can be discarded, and morality suspended. But in the realpolitik of nation-states, especially when it comes to shared natural resources, such romantic notions may be specious. Water, unlike territory or ideology, is not merely a symbol of sovereignty — it is a lifeline
Read about:
Indus Waters Treaty (IWT)
International Court of Justice (ICJ)
Key takeaways:
- The Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) was established not due to mutual goodwill, but out of pressing necessity. When British India was divided in 1947, the partition created two nations but left the water systems of the Indus basin split in a problematic way.
- The main control structures, essential for irrigation, ended up in India, while Pakistan, being downstream, depended entirely on the river flow.
- Tensions flared when India temporarily stopped water supply to Pakistan in 1948, prompting regional concerns. It was in this climate that the World Bank intervened, eventually facilitating what is now considered one of the most enduring and effective water-sharing treaties.
- Signed in 1960, the IWT assigned the eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas, and Sutlej) to India, while the western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab) were allocated to Pakistan. India was allowed limited use of the western rivers, such as for hydropower generation, under strict design and operational rules. This division reflected both geographical realities and the larger goal of maintaining regional peace.
- The treaty has survived several major conflicts — including the wars of 1965, 1971, and 1999 — as well as periods of severe diplomatic breakdown. Its resilience lies in its technical basis and its separation from political tensions. Even during conflicts, annual meetings between the Permanent Indus Commissions were held.
- The treaty includes a structured dispute resolution process involving bilateral talks, neutral expert assessment, and, when necessary, arbitration — all of which have helped maintain its functionality despite longstanding hostility.
- In recent years, India has increasingly questioned the treaty, particularly after terror attacks such as those in Uri (2016) and Pulwama (2019), which were linked to groups operating from Pakistan. Some Indian political voices began arguing that continuing to honor the treaty was unjustifiable under such conditions, and suggested leveraging water as a strategic tool.
- This rhetoric has emerged alongside India's expanding hydropower initiatives in Jammu and Kashmir, including the Kishanganga and Ratle projects. India asserts these are in line with treaty guidelines, but Pakistan contends that certain design elements could give India undue control over water flow, particularly in dry seasons, which could impact Pakistan’s agriculture and environment.
- Pakistan has responded by invoking the treaty’s adjudication mechanisms. In the Kishanganga case, Pakistan objected to India's water diversion. The Court of Arbitration, formed in 2010, ruled in 2013 that the project could continue, provided India maintained a minimum downstream flow and abided by restrictions on reservoir operations.
- The Ratle project sparked another legal dispute. India preferred addressing the matter through a neutral expert, viewing it as a technical issue, while Pakistan insisted on arbitration
- In 2016, the World Bank — the treaty’s administrative facilitator — temporarily halted both processes to avoid simultaneous proceedings. However, by 2022, it allowed both avenues to proceed, leading India to reject the arbitration process but participate in the neutral expert mechanism.
- This development is crucial. It reaffirms that the treaty's legal framework remains robust and likely to be activated if India ever attempts to exit the agreement. Rather than strengthening India’s position, a unilateral withdrawal could invite diplomatic backlash, legal consequences, and damage to India’s global standing.
- India has consistently advocated bilateralism in resolving issues with Pakistan, especially since the Simla Agreement of 1972. However, the IWT predates this pact and explicitly includes third-party resolution mechanisms. Neutral experts and arbitrators are not outsiders but are treaty-endorsed roles agreed upon by both nations.
- India's involvement in the Kishanganga and Ratle processes — however reluctant — underscores this fact. Therefore, referencing the Simla Agreement doesn’t invalidate what the IWT permits.
- South Asia isn’t unique in facing inter-state water disputes. Post-World War I Europe saw water-related disagreements, such as between Hungary and Czechoslovakia over the Danube.
- These were largely resolved through the League of Nations. In a more recent example, the GabÄíkovo–Nagymaros dispute between Hungary and Slovakia was settled at the International Court of Justice (ICJ), which urged both sides to uphold their treaty commitments.
- The Mekong River conflict in Southeast Asia also shows that cooperation via institutions like the Mekong River Commission, with its emphasis on transparency and information-sharing, can prevent escalation.
- These cases highlight a shared lesson: unilateral actions tend to lead to deadlock or conflict, while legal and diplomatic approaches offer a path to sustainable management of disputes.
- Unilaterally exiting the IWT would likely provoke international criticism and damage India's reputation as a reliable regional leader — particularly as it seeks greater global influence.
- The World Bank, as the treaty’s facilitator, may also be compelled to step in diplomatically or even legally. Such a move could also worry neighboring countries like Nepal and Bangladesh, complicating regional water cooperation.
- Legally, the IWT is binding, with no clause for withdrawal. Under international law — specifically the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties — a unilateral exit is only permissible under exceptional and narrowly defined conditions.
- Moreover, water is not just a strategic resource; it is a fundamental human right. Employing it as a retaliatory tool raises serious ethical concerns. Restricting water flow could harm downstream populations during critical periods.
- Even under the banner of national security, such actions could amount to collective punishment, which breaches moral norms. India's strength lies in upholding a rules-based order, not in weaponizing essential resources.
So, what is the way forward?
India is well within its rights to maximize its usage of the IWT’s allowances, such as constructing hydropower facilities in compliance with the treaty. The Kishanganga and Ratle projects are examples, although the latter remains contested. However, abandoning the treaty would undermine India’s legal and moral high ground and could isolate it diplomatically.
The IWT remains a remarkable example of cooperation in a tense geopolitical relationship. It proves that even bitter rivals can collaborate over vital shared resources like water. Dismantling the treaty would not only reverse decades of diplomatic progress but could also set a dangerous example for managing natural resources in conflict-prone regions
Follow Up Question
1.Consider the following pairs (2019)
| Glacier | River |
| 1. Bandarpunch | Yamuna |
| 2. Bara Shigri | Chenab |
| 3. Milam | Mandakini |
| 4. Siachen | Nubra |
| 5. Zemu | Manas |
Which of the pairs given above are correctly matched?
(a) 1, 2 and 4
(b) 1, 3 and 4
(c) 2 and 5
(d) 3 and 5
|
Answer (a)
Therefore, pairs 1, 2, and 4 are correctly matched |