INTEGRATED MAINS AND PRELIMS MENTORSHIP (IMPM) 2025 Daily KEY
| Exclusive for Subscribers Daily: Indus Valley Civilisation (IVC) and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) for the UPSC Exam? Why are topics like Collegium System and Reserve Bank of India (RBI) important for both preliminary and main exams? Discover more insights in the UPSC Exam Notes for September 23, 2024 |
🚨 UPSC EXAM NOTES presents the July edition of our comprehensive monthly guide. Access it to enhance your preparation. We value your input - share your thoughts and recommendations in the comments section or via email at Support@upscexamnotes.com 🚨
Critical Topics and Their Significance for the UPSC CSE Examination on September 23, 2024
Daily Insights and Initiatives for UPSC Exam Notes: Comprehensive explanations and high-quality material provided regularly for students
On the pitfalls of estimating GDP
For Preliminary Examination: Current events of national and international importance
For Mains Examination: GS III - Indian Economy
Context:
The ongoing GDP series is due for revision. The official agency is considering using GST data to estimate value addition. However, the agency should be careful to not apply unverified datasets and shaky methodologies without adequate testing and validations for GDP estimation
Read about:
What is Gross Domestic Product (GDP) ?
What is Gross Value Added (GVA)?
Key takeaways:
- Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is a crucial indicator of a nation’s economic scale and serves as a standard reference for comparing various metrics between countries or regions, such as tax obligations and welfare spending.
- To make GDP comparisons more meaningful, it is often expressed in “real” terms, adjusted for price fluctuations. The estimation of real GDP is based on a "base year" and involves extensive datasets on production, prices, and employment.
- This base year is revised every 5-10 years to reflect changes in prices and the structure of the economy. The National Statistical Office (NSO) is responsible for revising the GDP series, drawing on expertise across different domains.
- The current GDP series, which uses 2011-12 as the base year, is set to be updated, with 2020-21 proposed as the new base year. While most major datasets are available for this update, Census data is still missing.
- The NSO is considering using data from the Goods and Services Tax (GST) system to estimate value addition, potentially replacing the Ministry of Corporate Affairs’ MCA-21 database currently used for the private corporate sector, which contributes around 38% to GDP.
- The MCA-21 database was introduced in the last revision (2011-12 base year) to replace the Annual Survey of Industries (ASI) as the method for estimating factory manufacturing value.
- Previously, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) used a sample of large companies to estimate output for the non-financial corporate sector, but this approach was deemed insufficient as it missed value generated outside traditional factory settings.
- The MCA-21 database, which offers comprehensive corporate data from mandatory filings, was considered a more accurate representation of corporate output.
- When the 2011-12 base year replaced the 2004-05 series, the overall GDP showed a slight reduction in absolute size but an increase in growth rate. However, there was a significant discrepancy in the manufacturing sector’s performance.
- For example, the new series indicated a 5.4% growth in manufacturing for 2013-14, whereas the earlier series showed a contraction of 1.9%.
- This divergence raised concerns, especially since the revised industrial growth rate did not align with other economic indicators like bank credit growth and capacity utilization. Further investigation pointed to potential overestimation in the MCA-21 database.
- Despite this, the official agencies defended the revised GDP estimates, arguing that the use of the larger, more detailed MCA-21 database, along with improved estimation techniques, better captured the economy.
- Critics questioned whether a larger dataset truly resulted in more accurate data, especially since the government has not made the MCA data accessible for independent review.
- Over time, comparisons between manufacturing Gross Value Added (GVA) from the National Accounts Statistics (NAS) and ASI data revealed consistent overestimation by NAS. Between 2012-13 and 2019-20, NAS reported an average annual GVA growth of 6.2%, while ASI’s data showed only 3.2%.
- Similar discrepancies were found in fixed investment figures, further supporting concerns that NAS overestimates economic growth, particularly in manufacturing, when using MCA-21 data.
- This serves as a warning regarding the potential use of GST data in future GDP revisions. The NSO must ensure rigorous testing and validation of GST data before incorporating it into GDP calculations to avoid repeating the mistakes seen with the MCA-21 database.
- Pilot studies should be conducted to assess the suitability of GST data for measuring value addition across various industries and regions.
- Alternatively, the NSO might consider reverting to ASI for manufacturing estimates since this data is now available more quickly.
- GST data has the potential to significantly improve GDP estimates, but its reliability is still uncertain. Without thorough analysis and validation, incorporating it into official statistics could lead to questionable results, undermining confidence in GDP figures
Follow Up Question
1.A decrease in tax to GDP ratio of a country indicates which of the following? (UPSC CSE, 2015)
1. Slowing economic growth rate
2. Less equitable distribution of national income
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
(a) 1 only
(b) 2 only
(c) Both 1 and 2
(d) Neither 1 nor 2
|
Answer (a)
Considering these points, let's evaluate the options: (a) 1 only - This could be correct, as a slowing economic growth rate can lead to a decrease in the tax to GDP ratio. (b) 2 only - This is not necessarily correct, as the tax to GDP ratio alone doesn't directly indicate income distribution. (c) Both 1 and 2 - This is not correct because while statement 1 could be true, statement 2 is not necessarily true. (d) Neither 1 nor 2 - This is not the best answer because statement 1 could be true. Based on this analysis, the most appropriate answer is: (a) 1 only |
- India’s Constitution functions smoothly in conjunction with the executive and legislative branches. However, for the judiciary to wield democratic authority effectively, it must maintain a high degree of independence.
- This independence, though, can become problematic or undemocratic without constitutional checks, including rules of proper conduct and accountability. Without such safeguards, the judiciary could become arrogant in its power.
- In this context, Chief Justice S.H. Kapadia’s remarks on the need for balancing judicial accountability with independence during an event at the Supreme Court on Independence Day must be reconciled with Law Minister Salman Khurshid’s views on judicial propriety.
- Ensuring harmony among the three branches of government is essential for upholding the Constitution. Establishing clear guidelines for judicial behavior is crucial to prevent the judiciary from overstepping and to ensure it remains dignified and restrained.
- The Constitution outlines three key branches—the executive, the legislature, and the judiciary. The executive, led by the Prime Minister and Chief Ministers, is responsible for implementing laws and policies, operating under the rule of law.
- Parliament and state legislatures create the laws. When the executive or legislature acts arbitrarily or against constitutional provisions, the judiciary has the authority to intervene and issue directives under Article 143.
- The judiciary, which protects citizens' fundamental rights, holds a position of preeminence among the three branches but must also act within the framework of the Constitution.
- Felix Frankfurter emphasized that judges, like any other individuals or institutions, are not above criticism. While they are entrusted with justice, they are not immune from human flaws and can sometimes misuse their power. Therefore, criticism of the judiciary should be open and honest to remind judges of their public responsibility.
- As ultimate interpreters of the Constitution, judges must be both knowledgeable in law and culturally aware. Their role is pivotal in upholding constitutional values and laws, but concerns about the appointment process remain. Technically, the President appoints judges, though the decision originates from the Cabinet.
- The Constitution’s Preamble enshrines fundamental principles: India is to be a socialist, secular, democratic republic committed to ensuring justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity. However, the process for selecting judges and ensuring they embody these principles is not always clear.
- If the selection process is not transparent or principled, there is a risk that judges may come from the elite classes, leaving the working class without representation in governance.
- Winston Churchill acknowledged this issue in Britain, where courts were perceived to be biased in cases involving class conflict, even though they commanded respect in other matters. India faces similar challenges, where social justice often remains a mere promise.
- The introduction of the collegium system, established by a narrow Supreme Court decision, has further complicated the selection of judges. The collegium, which selects judges without a clear constitutional mandate, operates with little transparency or public involvement.
- There is no formal investigation into the backgrounds or qualifications of those selected, leading to concerns about the quality of judicial appointments.
- In response to these concerns, the Union Law Minister has proposed replacing the collegium with a commission. However, important questions remain about the commission’s structure, accountability, and guiding principles. A constitutional amendment that addresses these issues is necessary and can only be achieved through legislative action.
- A judicial selection commission must be of the highest caliber, led by individuals of equal standing to the Prime Minister or Supreme Court judges, with the Chief Justice of India as its chair. The commission must investigate the character, biases, and affiliations of potential appointees through an independent body, rather than relying on government-controlled agencies. Public input in the process is also essential.
- The commission must remain independent, aligned with constitutional values, and free from political or corporate influence. It should operate without fear or favor and be immune to legal challenges, with removal procedures overseen by a tribunal of senior judges. Ultimately, the people of India must have a voice in this process to ensure the judiciary serves the nation’s best interests
|
Answer (A)
The correct answer is A. the power of the Judiciary to pronounce upon the constitutionality of laws and executive orders. In India, judicial review refers to the judiciary's authority to evaluate the constitutionality of legislative acts and executive orders. If a law or order is found to be inconsistent with the Constitution, the judiciary can declare it invalid |
After a strong start to goods exports in the first quarter of 2024-25, momentum has slowed down. Export values dropped by 1.5% in July, hitting an eight-month low, and the decline worsened to 9.3% in August. This decline coincided with a record-high import bill of $64.4 billion in August, resulting in a merchandise trade deficit of $29.7 billion, the second largest after the $29.9 billion gap in October 2023.
Reasons for the widening trade deficit:
- Although exports have declined over the past two months, imports have not followed suit, increasing by 7.5% in July and 3.3% in August. This pushed the trade deficit to a nine-month high of $23.5 billion in July, widening further by $6.2 billion in August.
- While several of India’s top export sectors, such as petroleum and gems and jewellery, experienced significant drops (oil exports fell by 22.2% in July and 37.6% in August, and jewellery exports shrank by over 20% in both months), imports continued to rise.
- In August, slower growth in sectors like pharmaceuticals and electronics was observed. Additionally, with the slowdown in China’s economy, exports of certain goods such as stone, cement, and iron ore declined.
- However, as oil prices fell by $6 per barrel in August, India’s oil import bill dropped by a third to $11 billion, bringing the petroleum deficit to a three-year low, as noted by QuantEco Research economists.
- “The widening trade deficit was mainly driven by gems and jewellery, alongside smaller contributions from miscellaneous products and electronics,” the economists noted.
- While exports of gems and jewellery fell below $2 billion, India’s gold imports more than doubled in August to an unprecedented $10.1 billion.
- This contrasts with a 10.7% drop in gold imports in July and the $3 billion to $3.4 billion range seen since April. Trade officials attributed the surge to a reduction in the gold import duty from 15% to 6% in the Budget, rising gold prices, and jewellers stocking up for the festive season. Economists predict that the full effect of duty cuts on gold and other items will continue to impact the import bill in the coming months.
Could a wider trade deficit pose risks?
- “For a developing economy with high growth, the trade deficit should not be concerning as long as there are no foreign exchange issues,”
- Foreign capital inflows have remained positive in recent months, and India’s foreign exchange reserves reached a record $675 billion as of August 2, which the Finance Ministry noted is enough to cover 11.6 months of imports.
- Although this coverage may decrease if imports stay above $60 billion, strong services exports, which increased by over 10% from April to August, offer some reassurance.
What about foreign trade in goods?
While global trade is expected to grow faster in 2024 compared to 2023, demand remains weak in most developed markets. In addition to geopolitical tensions, the upcoming U.S. elections and increased tariffs on Chinese goods, coupled with China’s struggling domestic economy, pose challenges for countries like India.
As China's import demand weakens, it may seek to offload products in non-U.S. markets at lower prices. Furthermore, these factors are likely to keep oil prices down, negatively impacting India’s oil exports. Overall, concerns about global demand are increasing, and although India aims to increase goods and services exports to a trillion dollars each by 2030, the path forward will likely be challenging
1.The term "Twin Deficit" in the context of an economy refers to which of the following?
- Fiscal deficit and Revenue deficit
- Fiscal deficit and Current account deficit
- Trade deficit and Revenue deficit
- Trade deficit and Primary deficit
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
(a) 1 only
(b) 2 only
(c) 3 only
(d) 4 only
|
Answer (b)
The Twin Deficit refers to a situation where a country is facing both a fiscal deficit and a current account deficit. A fiscal deficit occurs when the government's total expenditures exceed the revenue that it generates, excluding money from borrowings. A current account deficit occurs when a country imports more goods, services, and capital than it exports. Both these deficits together can signify deeper economic issues, such as unsustainable borrowing or low competitiveness in international trade
|
- The health department activated the Nipah protocol by establishing 16 committees as outlined in the standard operating procedure for Nipah and began identifying individuals who had close contact with the victim after he exhibited symptoms approximately 10 days earlier.
- On September 15, Kerala's Health Minister Veena George announced, based on test results from the National Institute of Virology (NIV), Pune, that the man, a student in Bengaluru, had died from Nipah.
- This zoonotic virus can cause severe illnesses ranging from respiratory infections to fatal encephalitis. Following this confirmation, restrictions on social movement were enforced, and face masks were made mandatory in public areas of Malappuram district.
- This marks the second Nipah-related death in the Malappuram district within two months. On July 21, a 14-year-old boy from Chemrassery passed away from Nipah at the Government Medical College Hospital in Kozhikode.
- While this triggered an alarm and government-imposed restrictions, attention shifted to the neighboring Wayanad district due to Kerala's worst landslide on July 30. The Nipah cases from July 21 and September 9 occurred within 10 kilometers of each other in a densely populated area.
- The source of the virus remains unclear, although the boy was believed to have contracted it after consuming hog plum, and the method of transmission for the Bengaluru student remains unknown.
What is the history of Nipah in Kerala?
- Since 2018, Kerala has experienced six outbreaks of Nipah virus. A total of 22 people have died from the virus, with the first outbreak claiming 17 lives in Kozhikode and Malappuram. A 2021 outbreak in Pazhur, Kozhikode, led to one death, while the August 2023 outbreak in Kozhikode resulted in two fatalities. The recent incidents in Malappuram within two months have raised concerns that Nipah could become endemic in the region.
Why was there a delay in identifying the virus?
- The 24-year-old victim returned from Bengaluru in late August and sought treatment at various clinics after developing a fever and mobility issues on September 5. He was admitted to MES Medical College on September 8 with symptoms resembling meningitis or encephalitis and passed away the next morning. A physician’s suspicion led to testing of body fluid samples, which confirmed Nipah virus.
How did the government respond?
- The health department and local authorities swiftly designated five wards in the Tiruvali and Mampad panchayats as containment zones. Schools, madrasas, tuition centers, and anganwadis were closed, and shops were allowed to operate under limited hours. Social gatherings were prohibited, and masks became mandatory across the district, particularly for students and teachers.
- A route map of the victim’s activities was created, and 267 people who had been in contact with him were quarantined. These individuals, including his family, friends, and medical personnel, were closely monitored, with their serum samples tested at the virology lab—all results have been negative so far. Additionally, 30 of the victim’s classmates in Bengaluru were asked to self-quarantine.
- A Nipah control room was set up in Malappuram, and senior health officials, led by the director of the health department, K.J. Reena, have been monitoring the situation. Health workers conducted a field survey within a three-kilometer radius of the victim’s home, covering nearly 8,000 houses and identifying 175 fever cases, which were placed under observation. Psychological support was also extended to around 300 people.
What is the source of Nipah?
Bats are considered the primary carriers of Nipah virus. Transmission to humans occurs through consumption of fruits contaminated by bats or direct contact with the bodily fluids of infected individuals. Healthcare workers and family members of infected people are at high risk.
The origin of the infection in the 24-year-old remains unclear, and while bats are often implicated, experts are divided on this attribution. Efforts to eradicate bat colonies following the 2018 outbreak were unsuccessful, and a definitive link between Nipah and bats in Kerala has yet to be established
Follow Up Question
|
Answer (A)
|
- In 1902, Marshall arrived in India to serve as the director-general of the ASI. Before taking up his role, he studied several Indian artifacts in England, including three seals from Harappa at the British Museum, which were engraved with an unfamiliar script.
- In 1903, Marshall trusted his instincts and assigned Hirananda Sastri, the ASI’s 'pundit in charge' for Punjab, to explore three sites in the Ganga–Yamuna Doab region that had yielded copper tools.
- Marshall believed these copper hoards were linked to a Bronze Age culture, which he associated with the Early Vedic Age. Modern research, however, places these copper hoards within the Harappan timeline, although their age was uncertain at the time.
- Progress in research was slow due to the limited budgets of non-commercial departments in British India. Marshall had expressed a desire to excavate Harappa as early as 1907, but the costs of acquiring the land were beyond the ASI's financial capacity.
- The discovery of Harappa and Mohenjodaro did not come from one individual or occur all at once. The archaeologist Daya Ram Sahni uncovered evidence of an ancient culture at Harappa during a dig in 1921, and a similar pattern emerged in the unearthing of Mohenjodaro.
- Unlike the planned excavations at Harappa, the discovery at Mohenjodaro was not part of Marshall’s strategy. Rakhaldas Banerji, who led the ASI’s Western Circle, was eager to explore Mohenjodaro, which he believed to be a significant Buddhist site. During his excavation in the winter of 1922, Banerji’s assistant, N.S. Chikte, uncovered two inscribed seals.
- Banerji quickly realized that the inscriptions resembled those found on Harappa seals, revealing that Mohenjodaro was part of a vast, distinct culture spread across a large area. This significant finding made Banerji a key figure in the discovery of the Indus Valley Civilization.
- However, the ASI lacked an institutional framework for discussing ongoing research. There was no space for archaeologists to collaborate, brainstorm, or share insights from their fieldwork within the colonial-era ASI
1.Which of the following statements about the Indus Valley Civilization (IVC) is/are correct?
- The cities of Harappa and Mohenjodaro were discovered through the planned efforts of Sir John Marshall.
- The IVC is known for its advanced urban planning, including well-structured drainage systems and grid-patterned streets.
- The script of the Indus Valley Civilization has been fully deciphered and provides insight into their social and political structure.
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
A. 1 and 2 only
B. 2 only
C. 1 and 3 only
D. 1, 2, and 3
|
Answer (B)
|
| Subject | Topic | Description |
| History | Modern Indian History | Company rule and Crown rule 1773 - 1947 |
| History | Modern Indian History | Fall of Mughals |
| History | Modern Indian History | Establishment of British rule in India |
| History | Modern Indian History | Economic Policies of the British |
|
UPSC EXAM NOTES will be conducting both Prelims and Mains exams every Sunday as part of the Integrated Mains and Prelims (IMPM) Program. This program provides a comprehensive approach to UPSC exam preparation, ensuring that candidates are well-prepared for both stages of the exam. Program Highlights:
Duration: The IMPM plan is a one-year program, ensuring continuous and structured preparation over 12 months. With regular testing and consistent study guidance, this program is designed to maximize your chances of success in the UPSC exams |